I am sure we have all done it. Opened the Bible hoping that we are on the right page and will read the verses that we need just then, for consolation, for encouragement, for validation, for mercy. I certainly have. Sometimes the verses resonate immediately, and I have the sense that the Holy Spirit is answering my unspoken prayer. Other times I do not find what I think I need and admonish myself for taking such a cavalier approach to Scripture and to prayer. Recently I started to worry because in my daily Bible reading there seemed to be a recurring theme of reassurance that God was with me and I should not fear. I began to wonder what God was preparing me for!
‘So do not fear, for I am with you; do not be dismayed for I am your God. I will strengthen you and help you; I will uphold you with my right hand.’ (Isaiah 41:10)
As a mediator and dialogue facilitator, I have learned lots of techniques to create a safe space for other people to talk about their conflict, share their emotions and express their unmet needs. I explain that psychological safety means being able to share ideas, questions, opinions, and feelings without the fear of ridicule, humiliation, or punishment. Before we start a dialogue, I help people to agree the ground rules or principles they will follow during the conversation. The starting point is agreeing to listen to each other without interrupting and using respectful language, and we build from there. With help, they co-create a bubble in which they feel safe enough to engage in the difficult conversation. I hold them accountable to these shared principles, while supporting them to work through the issues, explore solutions and hopefully emerge from the bubble with new understandings and the beginnings of a conflict-free future relationship.
“Hopefully” is the operative word here.
When people in conflict ask if I think they can reach a settlement, or fix the issues, they want to know if the emotional toll of engaging in mediation will be worthwhile. They are looking for certainty of a positive outcome. Many mediators quote percentages of their cases that have resulted in settlements as a way of reassuring parties that it is worth giving mediation a go. The optimist in me always wants to reply, ‘I’m sure you can work this out.’
But as my practice has evolved, I have come to realise that there is a big difference between optimism and hope. Optimism is fragile and is based on a belief that a positive outcome is likely. When progress stalls, optimism can waver. Hope does not require certainty. It is more resilient. A hopeful mediator can say… ‘I don’t know where this conversation will end, but I believe there is value in staying engaged and exploring what is possible.’
It sometimes surprises me how exhausting it is to help other people to work through their conflict. Even when we are not directly impacted by the issues in dispute, or do not share the lived experiences of the people in conflict, peacebuilders inevitably take on some of the emotional burden. The curiosity and empathy that we bring into the work mean that people hand over to us, or unconsciously project onto us, their dilemmas, strong emotions, fears and hopes. Not just one person but each person, so now we are carrying multiple emotional bundles.
Of course, there are techniques for mediators and facilitators to hold these well, whilst simultaneously creating a safe space for dialogue and then facilitating the process. We can use mindfulness and grounding techniques, take things to supervision, and use reflective practice, but sometimes that is not enough.
Sometimes individual conflicts are manifestations of the wider societal and even geo-political landscape. In the face of structural inequality, deeply embedded polarisation, racism, antisemitism and islamophobia, my individual peacebuilding endeavours sometimes feel insufficient and futile.
My optimism often wavers. I ask why is Shalom… the flourishing that comes when relationships are rightly ordered and life is as God intends it to be… so elusive?
Peacebuilders need to have their own store of hope, so that they can continue to offer it to others. So, when and where do peacebuilders get to put down all those bundles?
Sometimes my only recourse is to lift my eyes to the mountains and ask God for help.
‘I lift my eyes to the mountains, where does my help come from? My help comes from the Lord, the Maker of heaven and earth. He will not let your foot slip – he who watches over you will not slumber.’ (Psalm 121:1)
When I am struggling to offer hope to people who are deeply hurting and desperately seeking to be seen and heard and understood by others, I picture myself in a cave in the mountains. In that safe space I remind myself of these verses.
‘Have I not commanded you? Be strong and courageous. Do not be afraid; do not be discouraged for the Lord your God will be with you wherever you go.’ (Joshua 1:9)
“My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” (2 Corinthians 12:9)
Psalm 46 reminds me that however big and catastrophic the world events that are unfolding, God is with us, He will make wars cease, He will break the bow and shatter the spear and burn the shields with fire.
And then He says, ‘Be still and know that I am God.’ (Psalm 46:10).
And I take that as an invitation to put down the bundles in the cave, and walk out into another day, to keep on trying in my small way, to invite Shalom into the world.
Sharon Crooks lives in London and works as a mediator, conflict coach, and trainer. She is a trustee of WMS, a community mediation service, and is passionate about helping people to communicate better to create peace in all its fullness.
Please note that the statements and views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of Contemporary Christianity.
Recent Comments