Over the last 3 years I have immersed myself in the history of First Armagh Presbyterian Church where I ministered for 28 years. After researching, reading, writing, proofreading, visiting libraries, churches and coffee shops, accumulating facts, stories and photos, with Paul Lutton’s help with proofreading, and David Acheson’s graphic designing… “Meeting Among the Spires, A History of First Presbyterian Church, Armagh 1673 -2023” was launched on Monday 9th March. It was then that I realised I had to get in touch with my inner salesman lest the 1,000 copies take up permanent residence in a basement store under those spires and I succeed in plunging First Armagh into debt.

So, I used multiple launches, speaking opportunities, every chance encounter, or even pulpit supply to sell books. I soon noticed how my mood became pegged to sales. A few good sales and confidence soared, while a no sale day lowered my mood and self-esteem.

I grew up in a business family. My father earned his self-esteem by selling cars and houses. I entered the ministry of the Presbyterian family on the assumption that God was calling me to put into practice some of my family’s business ideals. I would evangelise by selling Jesus in my community. I would encourage mission plans and incentivise with goals and targets. I would be a success in church as my father was a success in business. Now while I learnt much from my father about how to conduct relationships across traditional community divides, counterintuitively over 40 years ministry in East Belfast, Limerick, and Armagh I discovered God was teaching me that ministry was more about losing touch with my inner salesman. When we view ministry as a business, in which to succeed, it leaves some feeling utterly despondent and others becoming addicted to the adrenalin run of success. It reduces fascinating humans created in the image of God to potential consumers and it reduces the incomparable beauty of Jesus to just another commodity. I began to realise my inner drive to succeed in ministry was driven by the need to feel needed and important. It was easy to develop a Messiah complex.

Michael J Kruger’s recent book, “Bully Pulpit” is a salutary read highlighting the dangers of such complexes when ministry degenerates into sales talk.

I resonate with what Eugene Peterson, the American theologian of ministry wrote in his memoir, “The Pastor.”

“As I look back on a lifetime in the pastoral vocation what I remember most is a kind of messiness; a lot of stumbling around, fumbling the ball, losing my way, and then finding it again. It is amazing that anything came of it.”[1]

Interestingly my book on the history of First Armagh chronicles the lives of the 21 Ministers, and yes there is lots of messiness as well as faithfulness.

One of the other people who helped to deliver me from my inner salesman was another American poet and writer Wendell Berry who died on 31st August. HIs poems and novels celebrate God’s presence among the ordinary people who work amongst the wonder of God’s creation doing ordinary acts. His novel Jayber Crow is about a barber in his fictional town of Port William. In one memorable passage Jayber laments the young preachers who tried to sell a pre-programmed gospel in his local congregation.

“They had the mantle of power but not the mantle of knowledge! They would not stay long enough to know where they were. They learned to have a high opinion of God but a very low opinion of his works. In Port William the religion that scorned the beauty of the earth puzzled me.” [2]

We are called to live our lives before an audience of one. Writing the book has reminded me that the most important records are not in the safe in First Armagh, but in the heavenly places. As John the Baptist puts it when speaking of his relative Jesus of Nazareth John 3v30, “He must become greater and I must become less.”

Meanwhile, just in case you are wondering, “Meeting among the Spires “is available at £20 in Trimprint, Armagh, Presbyterian Historical Society in Belfast, First Armagh’s website, The Burning Bush Christian Book Centre in Dungannon, and from myself rev.t.davidson@icloud.com. Yes, a bit of the inner salesman remains!

Footnotes:
[1] E Peterson, “The Pastor” p314ff
[2] W Berry “Jayber Crow” p160ff

Tony Davidson is a former Minister of First Armagh Presbyterian Church.

Please note that the statements and views expressed in this article of those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of Contemporary Christianity.