As Contemporary Christianity publishes this piece, the curtains have not yet come down definitively on Keir Starmer’s time in office as UK Prime Minister. As Andy Burnham gets ready to fight the Makerfield by-election, the endgame may, in fact, still be some months off, and yet it feels the die is now irretrievably cast – that power is draining away from Sir Keir in a way that simply will not be recoverable.
There are things I do and do not get about prevailing public attitudes to Keir Starmer. I get that he has been, in all too many ways, an enormous disappointment: that the country was longing for a reset that his Government has manifestly failed to provide. I get that it is becoming ever more apparent that there is no such thing as ‘Starmerism’ and he seemingly had no proper plan for how to turn the UK around. I get that appointing Peter Mandelson as Ambassador to Washington was a dreadful error of judgment. And I recognise that there have been too many other mistakes along the way, such as the attempt to abolish winter fuel payments and additional National Insurance costs for employers.
But here is the thing I do not get. I do not understand where the visceral levels of hatred and contempt that are directed towards Keir Starmer come from. I recognise that he is dull and cautious but have also read that many who know him think of him as fundamentally decent. He comes across as incredibly earnest and hardworking, albeit his doggedness is now showing its shadow side in entrenchment and an apparent inability to read the room and see his time is up. Yes, there are many flaws, but – I ask again – is he deserving of intense no-holds-barred contempt for his performance and personality?
Perhaps I am naïve and foolish – too soft – but as we look at our Prime Minister, is there no room for compassion for someone failing in full public view and experiencing what is – to him – the betrayal of some colleagues? Is there no space to acknowledge the number and scale of national and international challenges facing anyone in his role? Some might say, of course, that nobody forced him to do the job, that he should not have sought the office of Prime Minister if he was not up to it, but how do you know if you can truly fill those shoes without stepping into them?
As a follower of Jesus Christ, the question that nags at me as I look at Sir Keir in both his pathos and stubbornness, is whether compassion is only for those I know in day-to-day life, those in family, work, church and community that I see face-to-face and look in the eye, but it’s not demanded at all of our attitudes to those in the public square? Are we called to show the fruit of the Spirit in our personal dealings with others, whilst at the same time being permitted to relish the wounding unravelling of those we only see in images on our phones, tablets, or TVs?
And – in terms of Christian character – can we really split our attitudes so easily? If I am gentle and kind in a coffee shop with a friend at 3pm, but say an hour later that someone in public life deserves zero sympathy, who is the true me? Do not judge others and you will not be judged, Jesus said, and beware too that the measure you use in weighing the lives of others will then be used against you. I cannot think of qualifications Jesus gave to those statements that give us an out for fundamentally non-Christian eviscerations of those in public life, when we would not dream of being so damning with people we actually know, given how that would undermine our sense of personal piety.
This is not the first time I have been tempted to write such a PS blog. I felt similarly strongly about the sad end to public life of the ministry of Justin Welby, someone who seemed to me to be of genuine Christian character and great giftedness, brought down by the complexity of a job where all the factions out to get him could never be pleased, and there were so many pitfalls he was bound to trip over and be unable to get up at some point.
I still shudder slightly at how uncharitable some Christians were towards this man – practically rubbing their hands with glee at his downfall – despite never having been in leadership roles of anything like that complexity. Justin Welby said that in the early months of his time as Archbishop, he was at times overwhelmed by the role, but some would dismiss that out of hand as a weak excuse. But would be so hard and uncaring if a real person sat in front of us and said they were overwhelmed?
In making these points, please do not get me wrong. There clearly needs to be scrutiny of those in public life and there must be accountability of failings. There comes a point when leaders fall short so substantially that the only good course of action is to step aside and let someone else step up. And we must also, of course, balance compassion with a measure of wisdom and shrewdness in how we evaluate those in public life.
But in the days and weeks to come, as we pray once more for UK public life and recognise that it is God who ultimately sets up and takes down rulers and those in authority, it would surely be good to also pause and pray for the man who leaves 10 Downing Street. It would be a true testament to Christian values to confess that we’re all people who have failed in small and sometimes big ways ourselves, and to pray that Sir Keir – a man made in the image of God and deeply loved by God – would not be left irreparably broken by his experience, but by God’s grace and goodness might rebuild his life and have rewarding times still in front of him.
Colin Neill is a member of Craigavon Presbyterian Church and a PCI Accredited Preacher.
Please note that the statements and views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of Contemporary Christianity.
Fully agree with Colin, compassion must be exercised both for public figures we only know from media, and for those we know personally in our limited worlds.
And more so.
And we need to avoid all forms of scapegoating – putting the sins / failings of some, on the shouldrrs of others. Didn’t we do this to our Lord Jesus. So Justin Welby and Keith Starmer. There is only one Sinless who sufferedbfor Sinners. Maybthe Holy Spirit give us all humility, & right judgment
Completely agree. If I may bang my drum for intercessory prayers, in how many churches are we praying for leaders such as Keir and others in difficult roles and so model compassion?
Thank you for this Colin. Totally agree.
It is difficult, sometimes impossible, to separate opinions and policies from those who promote them. It is easier to criticise a person, rather than critique the policy they promote.
An ad hominem argument provides grabby headlines, cheap laughs and quick take-downs. It’s hard to make jokes out of policy analysis. Being prepared to analyse policy in the first instance protects us from judging others as persons.
Multiple policy failures and misjudgements may render a person unfit to continue in leadership. Neither can we be naive. There are persons whose demonstrated morality is simply evil.
The character assassination and general nastiness which seems to have become normalised in so much public media is not a stance which is Christ like in any way.
‘Play the ball, not the man’.
I firmly oppose ad-hominem attacks as a means of political discourse — but sometimes the political issue is choices made by individuals. And then it is necessary to examine the person, and their judgement, and motivations.
I think, for those on the left of the party, there has been a feeling of betrayal since Sir Keir campaigned for the party leadership on the basis that he would continue with the previous leader’s policy platform — nationalising abusive and unscrupulous water companies, shifting the tax burden towards the richest, ending austerity and the 2-child cap, and so forth. When Sir Keir abandoned his pledges and began an increasingly vindictive purge of the left, they felt betrayed and used.
For Labour voters more generally, there has been a feeling that Sir Kier has squandered the largest landslide most can remember, with very little political change to show for it. And a profound disappointment that, on taking power, Sir Keir and his colleagues appeared to be hungry for freebies from organisations who should rather have been the subject of stricter scrutiny and regulation.
For those who hoped to see the end of the Tories’ draconian restrictions on the right to protest, there is huge disappointment with the prosecutor-turned-PM who gladly kept the repressive legislation, and oversaw the proscription of an organisation protesting genocide — treating them as the equivalent of loyalist and republican death squads, and prosecuting hundreds and hundreds of peaceful protestors against their overreach.
Many were outraged by Sir Keir’s almost complete failure to hold the Israeli government to account for their self-proclaimed acts of genocide in Gaza, in a disproportionate and counterproductive reaction to the 7th October attacks by Hamas. Shocked by the impunity for increasing attacks on Christians and Muslims in Jerusalem and the West Bank. Horrified by the UK’s provision of targeting intelligence and military-usable supplies to Israel, which renders us all complicit in the attacks.
For those who deplore the overt racism of the far right, and the somewhat less overt racism of the Tories, there is disappointment and anger as they see Sir Keir’s Labour Party channelling Nigel Farage, and pandering to his glib scapegoating of migrants for the economic ills caused by austerity and an increasingly unregulated and gouging corporate sector.
Then there is an increasingly right-wing press in the UK, with its constant drumbeat of criticism of even the sensible actions that Sir Keir’s government has taken, the downplaying of his few successes, and the amplification (and lack of scrutiny — even on TV current affairs broadcasting) of far-right politicians like Nigel Farage. This is aggravated by Ofcom’s refusal to enforce its impartiality rules on channels like GB News, on which right wing and far right politicians peddle their propaganda without any attempt at balance or fairness.
Finally, there is a profound lack of vision at the heart of Sir Keir’s authoritarian project, with no sense that the economic and political change the country so desperately needs will be delivered on his watch. On the contrary, their policy-forming bodies are increasingly populated by corporate lobbyists.
Sir Keir may, be in his way, a decent person — though he has a disturbing tendency to throw former allies under the bus in an attempt to deflect blame.
But — with a combination of sorrow, anger, and betrayal — people across the political spectrum have concluded in large numbers that the Labour Party needs new leadership, and that the PM’s position is becoming untenable — morally or politically.
The anti-PM sentiment is not purely personal. And where it is, it has a basis in his choices, his integrity, his instincts, and his (lack of?) vision for the economy, the country, and how politics should be carried on. Let’s not pretend it’s just personal mud slinging.